Friday the 13th New York NIGHTMARE on 42nd Street

Your Friday the 13th begins at the crossroads of the world: Times Square. The lights are blinding and each animated sign flashes so quickly it feels seizure inducing. Giant billboards proclaim NEW YORK CITY SUPPORTS TRUMP FOR SUPREME EMPEROR and CHICAGO: NOW STARRING WILLIAM HUNG AS BILLY FLYNN! You’re smashed shoulder to shoulder between tourists, selfie-sticks rise above the crowd like torches and pitch forks. “WHERE IS TIME SQUARE?” bellows into your ears at alternating intervals, always questioned with a whining southern twang. Sneakered feet move in unison, side to side like wind up dolls on their last crank.

friday the 13th nyc

A group of Elmos squeezes through the crowd, they circle you counter-clockwise, putting matted fur-covered hands on the small of your back and chanting “Picture? Picture? Picture?” You try to scream NO! but the yell is muffled by the chatter of tourists and the engine roar of double-decker sight-seeing buses. One of the selfie-sticks flashes, capturing an image of your stricken face, pale as chalk surrounded by the dirty red fur.

“5 DOLLARS!” the Elmos begin to chant, growing louder and more aggressive. They begin to chase you, nashing giant teeth that have suddenly grown out of the red fur. You manage to break free of the tourist mob and run. Elmos try to trip you, still shrieking “5 DOLLLLLLARS!!” but some how you make it down into the subway.


The Elmos fling themselves at the turn style, clawing for your wallet, your eyes, your butt cheeks. Their mittened hands are too clumsy to swipe a Metrocard! You make it out of Times Square and into the second chamber of terror: The New York Subway.

The light is dim and liquid drips from the ceiling. The screeching sound of subway breaks is unrelenting, penetrating the still, hot air that hovers between dirty green columns. Pools of vomit submerge each base. A raving drunk stumbles into you and you slip in the vomit, sliding off the platform down onto the subway tracks. You hit the ground and a wave of giant subway rats scamper across your body, making it impossible to arise. You hear the train approaching. The sounds of its horn blares, becoming louder and louder. Suddenly a hand reaches for you, hoists you back onto the tracks just in time.


You look up at your savior and see the disgusted face of your ex-girlfriend. The one who cheated on you, broke your heart, and you still think about sometimes when you touch yourself. She gives you a look of pity, wrinkles her nose at the smell of your vomit crusted hair, laughs scornfully and says, “Nice to see you. We should totally get coffee sometime,” then tongue kisses the gorgeous man standing beside her and disappears into the night.

You stumble, dazed onto the train. The car smells like piss and human excrement, or is the smell coming from you? The train screeches to a halt in the dark tunnel. The lights flicker. “We are experiencing train traffic ahead of us. We apologize for the inconvenience. Thank you for riding MTA New York City Transit.” In rapid succession, people burst into the train car.

An hour later you finally make it home: just in time for the horror grand finale. The streets of your neighborhood are eerily desolate. You can just make out muffled crying in the distance and a petit figure sitting on the stoop of your apartment building. As you get closer, your recognize the person’s features.


She’s a girl you met on Tinder, slept with once, and then ghosted. You back away but she sees you. Her face is streaked with tears. “WHY DON’T YOU LOVE ME!?” she sobs, “I HATE YOU! GIVE ME ANOTHER CHANCE! MEN SUCK! TAKE ME BACK!

You invite her upstairs. “This ending is a lot better than I was afraid of!” you smile to yourself.

You awake the next morning. She’s gone. You have a funny, funny feeling. You look down and see a rash spreading across your junk. A bed bug crawling in your chest hair. You reach for your iPhone 6S. In its place is a post-it note, “You get what you deserve, asshole!” is scrawled in girlish handwriting.

“NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!” You can’t stop screaming.

Happy Friday the 13th, NYC! Hope it’s nothing like this tale of terror! 

This post was originally published as a Halloween Horror Fest a couple years ago. But I think it works just as well, if not better, as a Friday the 13th scary story! Hope you agree 🙂

About New York Cliche

NYC lifestyle blog by Mary Lane. Events, adventures, epic mistakes, dating, life, humor. A 20-something trying to make it (and make out) in the city of dreams.

6 thoughts on “Friday the 13th New York NIGHTMARE on 42nd Street

  1. I like this. I like this style of writing a lot. I don’t know how I missed it the first time around. Is it discombobulating that I find your eyes in the last photograph quite appealing?..


    1. Hey thanks! It’s not hard to miss some of my posts…I’ll take this as incouragement to not be afraid to share old ones from the past! I don’t know if it’s discombobulating…maybe look into getting flame colored contacts? I’m sure someoe makes them!

    1. Hahahahaha. Thanks for keeping it light. Leah 🙂 But really, there is nothing that makes my skin crawl quite like those Elmos in Times Square! So much horror potential!

  2. It’s so appropriate that Times Square is a major setting for this tale of horror. Walking through there honestly makes my blood pressure spike. (And I might legitimately lay awake tonight out of fear of the bedbug.)


    1. Haha I worked there for 4 years and it made my blood pressure spike too! Not sure I trust anyone who *OMG* loves Times Square.
      Oh, and I’ve definitely lain awake for fear of bedbugs! Had such a scare over the summer- terrrrifying!! Thanks for reading 🙂

Comments are closed.